I was there. Nine years ago, today. Phish. Deer Creek. To quote Daddy... sickness.
7/25/99 Deer Creek, Noblesville, INDownload/listen link to 7/25/99 (courtesy of Phishows.com)
Set I: Meat, My Friend My Friend > My Left Toe > Whipping Post, Makisupa Policeman, Saw it Again, Boogie On Reggae Woman, Cavern
Set II: Birds of a Feather > Walk Away, Antelope, Suzy Greenberg, HYHU > Purple Rain > HYHU, You Enjoy Myself
Encore: Loving Cup
The boys opened up with Meat and I lost my shit. They played a rare My Left Toe from that weird Siket Disc, which I only got because my buddy Modeski used to work at Elektra and hooked me up with a copy.
Random fact... six out of 16 songs were covers. They busted out a covers of Whipping Post, Boogie On, Walk Away, HYHU > Purple Rain > HYHU, and encored with another cover... Loving Cup.